There’s tale upon tale told In praise of Washington’s Big Train And the horsehide deeds of Old Pete Shall be told often and again. And honest Matty, the Big Six Hurl’d more than a gem or two, But they can’t match The Rainmaker Tossed by Pittsburgh Dan McGrew.
He’d come by train from Keokuk As green as a patch of clover; And though he stood ‘bout six-foot-three Weighed one-forty or just over. He sauntered up to the owner Mister Dreyfus? I’m Dan McGrew, And I am the damnedest pitcher That anyone has ever knew.
Old Barney found himself amused By such a gangly cow-town rube So the boss man and Freddy Clarke Thought they’d have some fun with this ****. There’s Wagner—can you strike him out? His reply left them in stitches. I reckon that won’t be too hard; I should only need three pitches.
Oh, so your fastball is that good? Skipper Clarke said with a chuckle Don’t throw one, so Clarke said aghast Can your curve make Hans’ knees buckle? He shook his head, Nope, don’t throw that, As he grinned like a wiseacre. Got just one pitch, that’s all I need, And I call it The Rainmaker.
They called the Dutchman to the plate To knock him back to I-o-way And he swung early and swung late But couldn’t put one into play And Wagner grunted, moaned and screamed But found he couldn’t hit his stuff; Whatever this Rainmaker was It sure was plenty good enough.
He tossed the ball twenty feet high Just a soft lob with a stiff wrist And a slight twitch of his fingers To give it just a little twist Oh, it might swoop like a falcon Or drift as softly as a dove And often it would come down wet From touching rain clouds up above.
The clubs in the senior circuit Found themselves flummoxed by this lad: He no-hit the Bees in Beantown And drove the Cubs and Redlegs mad. He hasn’t got enough to hit! They growled in Brooklyn and Philly, But his ledger said otherwise; A gaudy twenty-six and three.
The final day of the season Found the Buccos and Giants tied, And no one doubted who would be Taking the hill for Pittsburgh’s side For New York, Matty took the hill And both hurlers were simply great Not one batter had crossed home plate As the two clubs completed eight.
The Giants bench hooted at him That beanpole throws like a girlie! But he got Doyle to pop up And then fanned Snodgrass on just three The next Giant to reach the plate Was the hard-hitting Red Murray And John McGraw said Now he’s done, Red will chase him in a hurry.
But Murray tapped the first pitch foul And missed the second one outright The Pittsburgh bench now taunted him Good morning, good noon and goodnight! McGrew than tossed one up so high His catcher swore it clipped a bird And then Dan strolled right off the mound As not a soul uttered a word.
The old ballpark is long gone now And those who toiled the same; That pitch still lives in infamy As does the pitcher and the game. The Bucs have had other heroes With deeds and feats of great renown But they still speak of Dan McGrew And his pitch which never came down.
"Mr. Thayer, Mr. Service. Mr. Service, Mr. Thayer."