"where are you from?"
"where are you really from?"
Go to questions; simple questions
some
may never think twice before asking them
"what is behind them"
"what are you saying?
When you ask someone solely based on their brown skin "where are you from?"
You are saying this "your skin is brown, so must not be from the here. Why, well there aren't brown people here anymore; we killed all the brown folks."
And what you are doing is verbally trying to wave your wand and vanish cultures that are present & still survive.
"Silly you, can't be brown and be from America. Where are you really from?"
Just wanted to make people conscious of the underlining assumptions they are making when they ask someone based on their brown skin color anywhere in America where they are from.
If you ask based on skin color you are inadvertently saying that brown skin cannot be from America and thus negating its history and letting yourself forget that you are in the Americas. On a continent of brown folks, why would they have to be white? Logically folks would be brown and of mixed descent.
Additionally, in the age of globalization, a question based on skin color is outdated. We all belong. We are all in it together no need to otherize people or make assumptions about them; get to know them and if it's important & relevant for someone to tell you their heritage, then they will at their own time.