Her eyes are what broke me It wasn’t the scars I always see past the scars But her eyes broke my heart Katie handed me the leash I could see she was crying Tears flowing from her brown eyes Brown eyes like Sandy’s But Katie’s were different Katie’s weren’t broken But Sandy’s were fine I like broken things. I hugged Katie tight “I’ll take care of here” Katie sobbed a little “It’s always hard.” I bet it was. In the car Sandy rode in the back But she cried and barked Some pain and some fear I knew she’d ridden in a man’s back seat I knew why she was afraid When I opened the car door she darted out I scolded her “Sandy no” She cried again I didn’t want to make her cry She’d been through enough I walked her through my yard Before shutting the gate And leaving her to explore on her own While I watched curiously She seemed alright I fed her dinner And watched her as she ate Selfishly on guard Keeping every last bit to herself It wasn’t her fault Just a habit Like the barking and crying From her crate All night long It wasn’t her fault She was a fighting dog It was how she felt safe But I hoped she’d learn She was safe And seven years later When my son patted her head Tears streaming from his eyes Brown like Sandy’s And broken like hers were once I looked into her eyes one last time They broke me again Even though they were no longer broken