Whatever happened to forever
Something about it faded away
Those promises you made will never come true
Cause we'll never be the same
I expected more than this short ending
I didn't know there'd be this pain
Now I wish I'd seen it coming
If I'd known, I wouldn't have stayed
If I could go back to when I met you
I'd change that October day

I know friends and love have a season
They come and go for a reason
But I just wish you never came
You lit up my life for a time
But somewhere down the line
You turned it all to gray

I'm always sad to say
That you and I have history
What I saw in you is a mystery
And for your future girlfriends, I'll pray
But wait, who would love you anyways?

I must admit
I miss our happiness
But I don't miss you

I must confess
I miss memories
But for you, I could care less

Whatever happened to forever
Something about it faded away
Those promises you made will never come true
Cause we'll never be the same
I expected more than this short ending
I didn't know there'd be this pain
Now I wish I'd seen it coming
If I'd known, I wouldn't have stayed
If I could go back to when I met you
I'd change that October day